The Aesthetic Guide is part of the Informa Markets Division of Informa PLC

This site is operated by a business or businesses owned by Informa PLC and all copyright resides with them. Informa PLC's registered office is 5 Howick Place, London SW1P 1WG. Registered in England and Wales. Number 8860726.

Patient dissatisfaction with cosmetic surgery avoided by building positive relationships

Article-Patient dissatisfaction with cosmetic surgery avoided by building positive relationships

Key iconKey Points

  • Expert encourages strong support of staff, as they are the ones who play large role in caring for patients
  • Surgeons must pay attention to their verbal, nonverbal language when communicating with patients

The best strategy for dealing with difficult patients is to avoid them in the first place, and success in that regard involves careful patient selection and multipronged efforts to provide the patient with a positive experience from beginning to end, says Howard A. Tobin, M.D.

Dr. Tobin
Under influence from his mentor, Richard Webster, M.D., Dr. Tobin says he decided in 1982 to limit his practice scope to cosmetic surgery. Among the many pearls he learned from Dr. Webster was that the way surgeons deal with their patients is just as important as their clinical acumen and surgical skill.

"There are many things that make patients dissatisfied," says Dr. Tobin, a private practitioner in Abilene, Texas, and clinical associate professor of surgery, University of Texas Southwestern Medical Center, Dallas. "It could be something you did, something you didn't do, or something they think you didn't do right, and the fact is, we don't always accomplish what we hope to in the OR."

"However, treating the patient well from the initial consultation until the end of the postoperative care will build a positive doctor-patient relationship that helps in preventing patient dissatisfaction, or dealing with it successfully if it occurs," he adds.

Treating patients well is a responsibility of the surgeon, but it also requires a supportive staff. Assuring the latter element is in place means making certain office personnel know they are appreciated and allowing them to develop to their full potential.

"Remember, your staff is your most important asset. They really run the practice and play a large role in taking good care of patients. This, in turn, will help to keep patients coming back," Dr. Tobin says.

LISTEN, LISTEN, LISTEN In their interactions with patients, surgeons must be cognizant of their communication skills, paying attention to their verbal and nonverbal language. Letting the patient talk without interrupting and listening with genuine interest are critical. It is also important not to talk patients into procedures they are not seeking in the first place.

"If you push for more, the patient agrees, and something goes wrong, you will be considered completely at fault," Dr. Tobin says, "whereas the patient is likely to be far more understanding if there is a problem with something the patient asked you to do."

In the initial consultation, surgeons should be watching for red flags that suggest a patient may not be a good match to the practice. As described by Vic Narurkar, M.D. (Cosmetic Surgery Times, March 2006), some signs of a "problem" patient include obsessive-compulsive behavior, a history of "doctor shopping," excessive rudeness or flattery, litigiousness and sudden whims. To this list, Dr. Tobin adds patients who bargain.

"You want to avoid patients who send bad vibes, but be diplomatic in declining their request for surgery, perhaps stating you don't think you would be the best surgeon to do what they need," Dr. Tobin says. "Don't flatly refuse to operate, because if you treat them with kindness and respect, they still may appreciate your thoughtful consultation and refer other patients."

ENSURE EDUCATION Ensuring the patient is properly educated about the procedure and its possible outcomes are also essential in preventing dissatisfaction, but this seems to be a weak area for some cosmetic surgeons. Dr. Tobin emphasizes that the information must be presented in terms the patient understands and be reinforced with additional resources (for example, online information or written literature), keeping in mind that patients will retain only a small percentage of the verbal information they receive in the office.

In his practice, Dr. Tobin uses materials developed in-office rather than stock literature, and presents slide shows highlighting outcomes of past patients. However, he limits the content of the latter to cases achieving average results. He is also careful that patients understand the risks and limitations of the proposed procedures.

"Promise less and deliver more, and you will come out ahead of the game," Dr. Tobin says.

In Dr. Tobin's practice, a follow-up letter is sent after each consultation, thanking the patient for coming in and reviewing the recommendations. It also asks the patient to read the literature they were given, and encourages them to come back or call with any questions.

"We rarely schedule surgery at the time of the consultation. Instead, it is better to allow patients time to go home and think," Dr. Tobin says.

Patients who have decided on surgery are also given the consent form in advance, not on the day of the procedure, so they have time to read it and develop questions. And on the day of the procedure, Dr. Tobin and other OR staff visit patients before surgery.

"Getting patients into a relaxed state when they go into the operation means they will be more relaxed when they come out," he says, noting that it may also be helpful to "bring your dog to work."

"My patients love to see my dog, and having my dog around helps my mood as well," he adds.

Hide comments


  • Allowed HTML tags: <em> <strong> <blockquote> <br> <p>

Plain text

  • No HTML tags allowed.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.